Image credit: ChatGPT illustration by Suzanne Kantra/Techlicious
Nearly 1 in 3 Amazon Black Friday deals offered no real savings, a new report from an economic policy group claims. Amazon says the analysis is "deeply flawed and false." Both are right. Here's why.
Of the products featured on Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025, nearly a third were available for the same price or less in the weeks before the sale, according to a Nov. 16 report from Groundwork Collaborative. About 1 in 10 cost more during the sale. Amazon disputes the findings, saying Groundwork included some products that never carried deal badges and used inaccurate prices in some comparisons.
The dispute arrives three days before Amazon's Black Friday Week sale starts on Nov. 19. And if you dive into both documents, the two sides turn out to be arguing over what the word "deal" should mean.
What the study found
Groundwork tracked 351 products from the curated pages where Amazon promoted what it called some of its best deals. Using price histories from Keepa, a service that records Amazon prices over time, the group compared each product’s lowest price during the sale with its lowest price in the 30 days before the event began.
The sale price was the same as or higher than that 30-day low for 29.1% of the products, with 9.4% being more expensive. Stretch the look-back to 90 days, and 57.3% of the products offered no savings over their recent low.
Tech shoppers will recognize some of the examples. Groundwork says the 46mm Apple Watch Series 10 sold for $679.99 during Black Friday 2025, 13% more than it cost nearly a month earlier. Beats Solo 4 headphones had already been priced at $129.95 12 days before the sale, and a Fitbit Charge 6 offered at $99.95 for Cyber Monday 2025 had hit the same price 20 days earlier.
"Shoppers trust that the deals advertised to them deliver real savings because Amazon promotes them that way," said Lindsay Owens, Groundwork's CEO and a co-author of the report. "If Amazon can't deliver that basic promise, lawmakers should hold them accountable."
Amazon's response
Amazon says its rule is simple: a product that carries a deal badge must be priced at or below its lowest price over the prior 30 days. By its own count, 98% of the products in Groundwork's sample met that test across 2024, and 99% did in 2025.
The company argues the sample was "cherry-picked," noting that only 17 of its top 200 best-selling deals were included out of more than 10 million deals across those events. It says Groundwork would count items that showed a strikethrough price but never carried a deal badge and misread Amazon's List Prices, which Amazon says it typically validates over 90 days.
Where the two sides split
The biggest gap between the two sides is timing. Take the Beats headphones. If the price dropped to $129.95 twelve days before Black Friday and stayed there, Amazon's rule would treat it as a legitimate deal, because it would match the lowest price of the past month. Groundwork would count it as no savings, because you could have paid the same price two weeks earlier. Both descriptions can be accurate at once.
The real takeaway for shoppers is that an Amazon Black Friday or Cyber Monday deal badge tells you the price isn't higher than its recent low. It doesn't tell you the price dropped specifically for the event.
Always check a deal before you buy
Our recommendation is to look at the price history on Amazon before you click "buy," especially on anything over $50. Amazon's Alexa for Shopping assistant can show up to 365 days of a product's price history if you ask. Keepa, the tracker Groundwork used, and CamelCamelCamel chart the same data for free for the life of the product, not just up to a year.
If the price regularly drops to today’s level, you may have another chance to buy at that price. If it’s the lowest you’ve seen in the past year and you were already planning to buy, it’s a good time to order. If the item was cheaper a few weeks ago, set a price alert and wait if you can.